In this article I want to talk about the Tough rule and the general idea of confidence in your list as a result of Tough on every model in your list.
To start things off I want to start out, like with many topics, with the actual rules for Tough:
Tough: When this model is disabled, roll a d6. On a 5 or 6, this model heals 1 damage point, is no longer disabled, and is knocked down.
This rules seems really simple. Statisticians (fancy word) would tell you the odds of rolling a successful tough roll is 2 out of 6 or 1 out of 3 or 33.34%. We can easily follow this math and even say that a 33.34%, being less than 50%, is not something that we should count on. However, any player who stands against a Trollblood army (barring any way to eliminate a tough roll all together) might think to themselves or say out loud "Gosh darn tough" or some other, more colorful, phrase.
Why? Why do people look at this and immediately think "FML?" Lets look at it from an army points perspective. I have a list that I recently played in a local tournament. It looks like this:
Grissel Bloodsong, Fell Caller (+5)
-Storm Troll (+5)
-Pyre Troll (+5)
Fell Caller Hero (3)
Horthol, Long Rider Hero (5)
Fennblade Kithkar (2)
Stone Scribe Chronicler (2)
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes (min) (3) + Elder (1)
Trollkin Fennblades (max) (8) + UA (2)
Long Riders (max) (11)
Trollkin Warders (max) (8)
At first glance you see a very light beast package with 45 army points of infantry. However, when we look at the average success rate of Tough (33.34%) and apply it to the number of army points that have the Tough rule (45) we could say that with Tough we are looking at a 65 point army instead of a 50 point army. For those scratching their heads wondering what I am talking about:
pGrissel (+5)
-Storm Troll (5)
-Pyre Troll(5)
45 Points of Infantry with Tough.
33.34% of those models will succeed in their tough roll and have to be killed again = 15 points of models will succeed in their tough roll.
45 points of starting infantry + 15 points of infantry that will succeed in tough = 60 points of infantry
Therefore, when you re-add the battlegroup you are looking at, theoretically, a 65 point army. Nevermind the fact that every Troll caster has tough, as well. I am not smart enough to factor in what that means. It is just a bonus.
So what? In this game, we all look for ways to gain an edge on our opponent. Some players look to theme forces to gain cheaper models or free models to add to their list to try and tip the scale in their favor.
Looking at this vein lets look at our two most famour theme forces in Trollbloods: Runes of War and Family Reunion.
Runes of War:
Hoarluk Doomshaper, Shaman of the Gnalrs (+7)
-Mulg the Ancient (12)
-Diretroll Mauler (9)
-Earthborn Dire Troll (10)
-Troll Axer (6)
Krielstonebearer and Stone Scribes (max) (4) + Elder (1)
Janissa Stonetide (3)
Runeshapers (3)
Runeshapers (3)
Runeshapers (3)
Runeshapers (3)
Many people have seen this list and either cringed at the Mulg assassination or all the darn magic attacks getting through their tricky incorporeal models. If we look at the list based off the point reduction of the Runeshapers and tough were are looking at 4 free points from the Tier Bonus and another over 6 points from tough on the infantry models giving you a 60 point list against your opponents 50 point list.
Family Reunion:
Borka Kegslayer (+5)
-Pyg Keg Carrier
-Pyre Troll (5)
-Swamp Troll (4)
Trollkin Champion Hero (3)
Trollkin Champion Hero (3)
Trollkin Champion Hero (3)
Stone Scribe Chronicler (2)
Trollkin Champions (max) (9) + Skaldi Bonehammer (3)
Trollkin Champions (min) (5)
Trollkin Champions (min) (5)
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes (min) (3) + Elder (1)
Greygore Boomhowler & Co. (max) (9)
The tier bonus gives you 3 extra points and an extra 15 points in tough (specifically 5 or 6) giving you a 68 point army. When we factor in that 9 points have a 50% success rate in their tough roll this makes this list even larger. Once again, I am not smart enough to figure this out for you so just imagine that Boomhowler makes your army even bigger than 68 points.
Why? Why is this significant? In simple terms, once you realize that you are beginning your game with many more points than your opponent brought to fight you, you play a lot more aggressively with your army and shove them forward without fear of losing some models. You now that you will lose some. This game would be garbage if you never killed anything or lost anything. However, when you know that the first 10-15 points to die might be the last to die it puts you in a state of "I got this." I have never played against Trolls, only on the delivering end, but I imagine we look like bloodthirsty crazy hordes of murdering maniacs. Doomreaver spam players might understand what I mean, too. In most cases even if I push all of my models forward and only gain 1" of table space I feel like I am gaining ground and everything I am doing is worthwhile, because I am gaining ground.
I, personally, feel like playing Trollbloods is like playing with a meat grinder. I am going to push my meat grinder toward your army and eat away at it until their is nothing left. Playing Trollbloods is not for the timid. Your infantry models are gong to die, tough or not. They have a job to do and so you need to get them in the fight to do their job. I am a very scenario minded player, so I factor that into my lists as well, but I hope to kill every single model you thought was going to kill me in the process just to solidify the message that Trolls are Tough.
I will be totally honest here, if I were ever to play a faction besides Trollbloods again, I would look for factions that can bring Rhupert and any other way to bring Tough models to the game. For me, if you break my armor and the model just dies, I don't understand what just happened. I feel cheated and it kind of puts me on tilt. Long live Rhupert Corvolo and the Gatorman Witch Doctor...AND TROLLBLOODS!
Thank you for taking the time to read this article. I hope I have given Trollblood, and every other faction, players a different way of looking at the Tough rule and the mindset that can develop as a result of Tough. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.
~IAmSweeps