Friday, December 27, 2013

A "Tough" Mental Game

Welcome to another Kith, Kriel, and Kin article. As always, I am Kyle (IAmSweeps on the various interwebs).

In this article I want to talk about the Tough rule and the general idea of confidence in your list as a result of Tough on every model in your list. 

To start things off I want to start out, like with many topics, with the actual rules for Tough: 

Tough: When this model is disabled, roll a d6. On a 5 or 6, this model heals 1 damage point, is no longer disabled, and is knocked down. 

This rules seems really simple. Statisticians (fancy word) would tell you the odds of rolling a successful tough roll is 2 out of 6 or 1 out of 3 or 33.34%. We can easily follow this math and even say that a 33.34%, being less than 50%, is not something that we should count on. However, any player who stands against a Trollblood army (barring any way to eliminate a tough roll all together) might think to themselves or say out loud "Gosh darn tough" or some other, more colorful, phrase. 

 Why? Why do people look at this and immediately think "FML?" Lets look at it from an army points perspective. I have a list that I recently played in a local tournament. It looks like this:
   
WP_20130918_016 (1)

Grissel Bloodsong, Fell Caller (+5)
-Storm Troll (+5) 
-Pyre Troll (+5) 
Fell Caller Hero (3) 
Horthol, Long Rider Hero (5)
Fennblade Kithkar (2) 
Stone Scribe Chronicler (2) 
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes (min) (3) + Elder (1) 
Trollkin Fennblades (max) (8) + UA (2) 
Long Riders (max) (11) 
Trollkin Warders (max) (8) 

At first glance you see a very light beast package with 45 army points of infantry. However, when we look at the average success rate of Tough (33.34%) and apply it to the number of army points that have the Tough rule (45) we could say that with Tough we are looking at a 65 point army instead of a 50 point army. For those scratching their heads wondering what I am talking about: 

pGrissel (+5) 
-Storm Troll (5) 
-Pyre Troll(5) 
45 Points of Infantry with Tough. 

33.34% of those models will succeed in their tough roll and have to be killed again = 15 points of models will succeed in their tough roll. 

45 points of starting infantry + 15 points of infantry that will succeed in tough = 60 points of infantry 

Therefore, when you re-add the battlegroup you are looking at, theoretically, a 65 point army. Nevermind the fact that every Troll caster has tough, as well. I am not smart enough to factor in what that means. It is just a bonus. 

So what? In this game, we all look for ways to gain an edge on our opponent. Some players look to theme forces to gain cheaper models or free models to add to their list to try and tip the scale in their favor. 

Looking at this vein lets look at our two most famour theme forces in Trollbloods: Runes of War and Family Reunion.
   
WP_20131117_004 (1)

Runes of War: 
Hoarluk Doomshaper, Shaman of the Gnalrs (+7) 
-Mulg the Ancient (12) 
-Diretroll Mauler (9) 
-Earthborn Dire Troll (10) 
-Troll Axer (6) 
Krielstonebearer and Stone Scribes (max) (4) + Elder (1) 
Janissa Stonetide (3) 
Runeshapers (3) 
Runeshapers (3) 
Runeshapers (3) 
Runeshapers (3) 

Many people have seen this list and either cringed at the Mulg assassination or all the darn magic attacks getting through their tricky incorporeal models. If we look at the list based off the point reduction of the Runeshapers and tough were are looking at 4 free points from the Tier Bonus and another over 6 points from tough on the infantry models giving you a 60 point list against your opponents 50 point list.

71021_BorkaKegslayer_WEB
   
Family Reunion: 
Borka Kegslayer (+5) 
-Pyg Keg Carrier 
-Pyre Troll (5) 
-Swamp Troll (4) 
Trollkin Champion Hero (3) 
Trollkin Champion Hero (3) 
Trollkin Champion Hero (3) 
Stone Scribe Chronicler (2) 
Trollkin Champions (max) (9) + Skaldi Bonehammer (3) 
Trollkin Champions (min) (5) 
Trollkin Champions (min) (5) 
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes (min) (3) + Elder (1) 
Greygore Boomhowler & Co. (max) (9) 

The tier bonus gives you 3 extra points and an extra 15 points in tough (specifically 5 or 6) giving you a 68 point army. When we factor in that 9 points have a 50% success rate in their tough roll this makes this list even larger. Once again, I am not smart enough to figure this out for you so just imagine that Boomhowler makes your army even bigger than 68 points. 

Why? Why is this significant? In simple terms, once you realize that you are beginning your game with many more points than your opponent brought to fight you, you play a lot more aggressively with your army and shove them forward without fear of losing some models. You now that you will lose some. This game would be garbage if you never killed anything or lost anything. However, when you know that the first 10-15 points to die might be the last to die it puts you in a state of "I got this." I have never played against Trolls, only on the delivering end, but I imagine we look like bloodthirsty crazy hordes of murdering maniacs. Doomreaver spam players might understand what I mean, too. In most cases even if I push all of my models forward and only gain 1" of table space I feel like I am gaining ground and everything I am doing is worthwhile, because I am gaining ground.

I, personally, feel like playing Trollbloods is like playing with a meat grinder. I am going to push my meat grinder toward your army and eat away at it until their is nothing left. Playing Trollbloods is not for the timid. Your infantry models are gong to die, tough or not. They have a job to do and so you need to get them in the fight to do their job. I am a very scenario minded player, so I factor that into my lists as well, but I hope to kill every single model you thought was going to kill me in the process just to solidify the message that Trolls are Tough. 

I will be totally honest here, if I were ever to play a faction besides Trollbloods again, I would look for factions that can bring Rhupert and any other way to bring Tough models to the game. For me, if you break my armor and the model just dies, I don't understand what just happened. I feel cheated and it kind of puts me on tilt. Long live Rhupert Corvolo and the Gatorman Witch Doctor...AND TROLLBLOODS!  

Gladiator-movies-15324569-1280-800

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. I hope I have given Trollblood, and every other faction, players a different way of looking at the Tough rule and the mindset that can develop as a result of Tough. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.

~IAmSweeps
MKII-Troll-Logo-Thumb

Tuesday, December 24, 2013

Smashing the Competition with Power Attacks

Welcome back to another Kith, Kriel, and Kin article. As always, I am Kyle (IAmSweeps on the various interwebs). 

In this article I want to tackle a near and dear topic to every Trollblood's heart, Power Attacks. Out of all of the factions, I personally believe that Trolls were made to use as many Power Attacks in a game as you have activations. Eh, maybe that is a little excessive, but maybe not.

I posted a poll a few weeks ago asking players what Power Attacks they use on a regular basis. 103 voters participated, which was the best Kith, Kriel, and Kin poll yet (THANKS EVERYONE!). You will find under each section below the rules associated with each power attack. The results of the poll look like this:

Power Attacks


Headbutt 38 (36%) 

Rules: The attacking model make a melee attack roll against its target. If the attack hits, the target is knocked down and suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attacker's current STR.

A model cannot head-butt while held in a headlock. A model cannot head-butt a model with a larger base.

headbutt

My thoughts: I think that headbutts are an amazing option to take down big targets that can be knocked down. Lets look at an example. Hoarluk Doomshaper (prime) sends in Mulg with the Fortune upkeep spell and the Rush animus waltzing up to a DEF 14 Feral Warpwolf that warped ARM. We will assume Mulg was damaged the turn before. Let's face it, he probably isn't going to advance 4" and get close enough to headbutt a Feral Warpwolf, even with Rush. Once he gets there you would think that with Fortune the odds of hitting the Feral without boosting (82.6%) are good enough, but we want to make our chances even better because we need this guy knocked down to make sure he dies. Boosting to hit with the headbutt raises the probability with Fortune to 99.1%. I like those odds much better. Once he is knocked down you have 4 attacks above ARM to buy and 1 more if it happens to still be alive with Doomshaper's affinity, which should be more than enough to remove the pesky Feral. Many people would feel like the initial probability of 82.6% to hit with each attack, a charge bonus die of damage, then a non-charge initial, 4 bought clubs, and a free club if it is still alive is good enough for them and that may be why only 36% of participant in the poll voted for this power attack. However, lets say that Feral is the only thing left alive that has a chance at killing Mulg, by knocking it down and ensuring that every punishing club hits, you might find yourself in a much more favorable situation. Since dice happen in this game, I prefer to take the chance of failure out of as many things as I can control. I like to use probabilities when explaining things but I am by no means an expert in statistical analysis. I know a higher number percentage means it is more likely to succeed. I am sure as I gain more experience I may feel more comfortable with the 82.6% with 2 dice and Fortune to hit, or even the 90.7% with 3 dice and no Fortune. Until then, I'm headbutting anything that I need to put a lot of damage into. 

A note on models that can not be knocked down: There are many models in the game that can not be knocked down for one reason or another. It is important to know that a model that is hit with a Headbutt Power Attack still takes a damage roll equal to the attacking model's current STR. So, if a Dire Troll Mauler succeeds in a Chain Attack: Grab and Smash cannot headbutt a colossal (because it has a larger base) and would not be able to cause it damage equal to the Mauler's STR. However, if a Heavy with Steady (from whatever source) is in the same situation, the Mauler can headbutt that model and cause damage equal to it's current STR. 

Push 9 (8%) 

Rules: A push power attack automatically hits and deals no damage. Both models roll a d6 and add their STR. If the defender's total is greater, it resists being pushed. If the attacker's total equals or exceeds the defender's, the defending model is pushed 1" directly away from the attacker. After a model is pushed by a push power attack, the attacker can immediately advance directly toward the pushed model up to the distance the pushed model was moved.

Being Pushed: A pushed model moves at half rate through rough terrain, suffers the effects of any hazzards it moves through, and stops if it contacts an obstacle, obstruction, or another model. 

Remember that a pushed model is not advancing and therefore cannot be targeted by free strikes during the movement. 

A pushed model falls off elevated terrain if it ends its push movement with less than 1" of ground under its base. See "Falling" (p. 63) for detailed rules on determining damage from a fall.  

Push-Start-a-Car

My thoughts: I am actually surprised that only 8% of players use Push on a regular basis. There have been countless times where I measure my control area to a flag and it is just outside my regular advance range, I don't have anything I can really charge to get there, and I definitely don't want to just run. Hazzah! I can use this light beast that was just going to bank me Fury this turn anyway to push me that inch I needed to get there. I know. If I have positioned my warlock better in the first place I wouldn't need to push. Plans change and I don't want an inch to be the reason why I cant apply scenario pressure to my opponent. A push can also be used to move a model that is sitting, "toe in the zone", out. A push can be used to get an extra inch on a wicked assassination run. The only thing that would make a push better is if you could spend extra Fury/Focus to push farther. We can dream, right? 

Slam 55 (53%) 

Rules: Any effects that prevent a model from charging, such as a penalty to its SPD or movement for any reason other than for being in rough terrain, also prevent the model from making a slam power attack. A slamming model can advance through rough terrain. A model must have both its normal movement and action available in order to use its normal movement to make a slam power attack. 

During its activation, a model can attempt to slam any model that is in its line of sight at the beginning of its normal movement. A knocked down model can not be moved by a slam. 

Declare the slam attempt and its target before moving the model. 

Declare the slam attempt and its target, then turn the slamming model to face the slam target directly. The slamming model then advances its full SPD plus 3" directly toward its target. The slamming model cannot voluntarily stop its movement unless its target is in its melee range, but it can end this movement at any point with its slam target in its 0.5" melee range. It must stop if it contacts a model, an obstacle, or an obstruction. The slamming model cannot change its facing during or after this movement. 

A slamming model that ends its slam movement with its slam target in its 0.5" melee range has made a successful slam. If it advanced at least 3" it makes a melee attack roll against its target. A model that power attack slams a model with a larger base suffers -2 on its attack roll. If the attack hits, the target is slammed directly away from the attacker (see "Being Slammed," next). 

If a slamming model makes a successful slam but moved less than 3", it has not moved fast enough to get its full weight and power into the blow. The model makes an attack roll against its target. If the target is hit, it suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attacker's current STR but is not slammed. These are still slam attack rolls and slam damage rolls. 

A model that does not end its slam movement within 0.5" of the target has failed its slam power attack. If a model fails its slam power attack during its activation, its activation ends. 

Being Slammed: A slammed model is moved d6" directly away from its attacker and is then knocked down. If the slamming model has a smaller base that the slam target, the model is slammed half the distance rolled. It then suffers slam damage as described below.

A slammed model moves at half rate through rough terrain, suffers and damaging effects through which it passes, and stops if it contacts an obstacle, an obstruction, or a model with an equal or larger sized base. If a slammed model cannot be knocked down, it must still forfeit its action or movement if it activates later in a turn in which it was slammed. 

A slammed model moves through models with smaller bases than its own. If it would end up on top of a model, follow the rule of least disturbance (p.64) to move the models into legal positions. A slammed model falls off elevated terrain if it ends its slam movement with less than 1" of ground under its base. See "Falling" (p. 63) for detailed rules on determining damage from a fall. Resolve any falling damage simultaneously with slam damage. 

Slam Damage: Apply slam damage after movement and knockdown effects, regardless of whether the model actually moves or is knocked down. The model hit suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attackers current STR. Add an additional die to the damage roll if the slammed model contacts an obstacle, an obstruction, or a model with an equal or larger sized base. Slam damage can be boosted. 

Collateral Damage: If a slammed model contacts a model with an equal-sized base or moves through a model with a smaller base, that model is knocked down and suffers collateral damage. A model suffering collateral damage suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attacker's current STR. Collateral damage cannot be boosted. A contacted model with a larger base than the slammed model does not suffer collateral damage and is not knocked down. Resolve any collateral damage simultaneously with slam damage. Collateral damage is not considered to be damage from an attack or model. For example, an effect triggered by being "damaged by an enemy attack" would not trigger due to collateral damage. 

slam

My thoughts: Slams can be an boon or a trap. One thing that Trollbloods have at their disposal that no other faction has is Longriders, and Longriders can slam as a part of the Bull Rush order. One of my favorite ways to use this power attack is under the command of pGrissel I send in Longriders to slam a flank towards the middle of my opponents army, then use Grissel's "Hoof It" fell call on them so at the end of the turn they can either advance further forward on the flank to threaten my opponent's support line or pull them back to potentially do it again next turn. This can be a trap, like I said before, where you slam but then your Longriders are just sitting their to eat a charge because they actually kill the model they slammed. It works out pretty slick if you can slam a model back, knocking them down, in front of a line of your opponents models who cannot charge you because they have this knocked down model in their way. At POW 14 on their mount the model is probably dead. Outside of trolls I have seen and heard of players using their arc nodes as slam bots, getting into places they otherwise couldn't to arc devastating spells at our low DEF troops. So, keep that in mind when playing against Cryx and maybe even Menoth (less common). An interesting note is that if you slam a model of say, small or medium base size (most caster's base sizes) into a larger bases size, obstruction or obstacle you gain an additional die AND slam damage can be boosted. This is a long shot, but if you can get a beast, who can hit a caster, and you slam them into a wall (or larger base or obstruction) and boost damage you are looking at 4 damage dice for damage. I hope. I hope. I hope. I hope, that you gave them the Mauler's animus AND are under the Krielstone aura because that can end a came quick, fast, in a hurry, and leave time for tea. 

Trample 68 (66%) 

Rules: Any effects that prevent a model from charging, such as a penalty to its SPD or movement for any reason other than for being in rough terrain, also prevent the model from making a trample power attack. A trampling model can advance through rough terrain. A model must have both its normal movement and action available in order to use its normal movement to make a trample power attack. Light warjacks/warbeasts cannot make trample power attacks. 

Declare a trample power attack at the beginning of the model's normal movement. Choose a direction in which you wish to trample, and turn the model to face that direction. The model then advances up to its current SPD plus 3" in a straight line in that direction. It moves through any small-based model in its path, but there must be room for the trampling model's base at the end of the movement. It stops if it contacts a model with a medium or large base, an obstacle, or an obstruction. The trampling model cannot change facing during or after this movement. Do not resolve free strikes against the trampling model during this movement. 

After the model has finished its trample movement, it makes a melee attack roll against each small-based model through which it moved during this movement. Models hit by a trample attack roll suffer a damage roll with a POW equal to the current STR of the trampling model. Trample damage can be boosted. If a trampling mode first contacts the front arc of a model in Shield Wall, that model gains its Shield Wall ARM bonus when resolving damage for a trample. 

Resolve free strikes against the trampling model after resolving all trample attacks. Models contacted cannot make free strikes against the trampling model. Ignore the distance between models when resolving free strikes against the trampling model; if a model was eligible to make a free strike against the trampling model during the trampling movement it can do so whether or not the trampling model ended its movement in the eligible model's melee range.  

trample

My thoughts: I have 2 words to say followed by two words when it comes to trample power attacks: "Dire Trolls" and "War Wagon." Are you kidding me? One possible exception to Dire Trolls is Mulg because normally he is SPD 4 but if he got damaged and you have access to Rush from the Axer and he is Trampling 11" with reach at base MAT 7... Sure his POW on trample attacks is only his STR but I personally think the hard part is hitting on a trample power attack. Once you hit things they typically just die. Beyond Mulg the SPD of the other Dire Trolls and the War Wagon make them really awesome Trampling models. When I play a list with a heavy, any heavy, I constantly look at my opponent's caster and think "How can I get there to eat that little...warcaster/warlock?" In that line of thinking the idea of Trampling always pops into my head. Since our beasts are typically Fury 5, using 1 Fury to trample to make sure I get there is well worth it more often than not.

Head Lock/Weapon Lock 2 (1%) 

Rules: A model making a headlock/weapon lock can lock a warjack or warbeast's weapon or head and prevent its use if the target has an equal- or smaller-sized base. A warjack/warbeast must have at least one non-crippled Open Fist to make a headlock/weapon lock power attack. Declare what the attacking model is attempting to lock before making the attack roll. 

When a warjack/warbeast makes a headlock/weapon lock, also declare which weapon with Open Fist it is using to make the attack before making a melee attack roll. A knocked down model can not be locked. If the attack hits then the specified head/weapon is locked. Headlock/weapon lock attacks do not cause damage. 

Maintaining Locks and Being Locked When a weapon is locked the target model cannot make attacks with the locked weapon along with all other weapons in the same location. Locking a weapon with a location of "-" has no effect on other weapons. A model held in a headlock cannot make attacks with any weapons located in its head (H). A model held in a headlock/weapon lock cannot make special attacks. 

While involved in a lock, the attacker cannot make special attacks or attack with the weapon with which it made the lock attempt, nor can it use any other weapon in the same location. The attacker and the defender are free to attack with any of their other melee weapons. 

A locked model can choose only to make a combat action as its action and cannot make a special attack. At the beginning of its combat action, a model suffering a headlock/ weapon lock must attempt to break the lock. When a break attempt is made, both models involved in the lock roll a d6 and add their STR. If the locked model's total exceeds that of the model holding the lock, the lock is broken. The locked model can make its initial attacks with any melee weapons not located in a locked system as normal. After resolving these attacks and attempts to break free, a model can spend focus points to make more attempts to break a lock or to make additional attacks with usable weapons, at 1 focus point per break attempt or additional attack. Once a lock is broken, the model can use the weapon that was locked. A model can voluntarily release a lock it is maintaining at any time during its activation. At any time during its activation, a model can voluntarily release a lock it is maintaining. 

Neither model can advance or be pushed while involved in a lock. A lock is broken automatically if:
  • An effect causes either model to move or be placed;
  • An effect knocks down either model;
  • An effect causes either model to become incorporeal;
  • An effect causes the attacker to become stationary;
  • The weapon system maintaining the lock is crippled; or
  • Either model is destroyed or removed from play.
headlock

My thoughts: I don't mean to insult Privateer Press or say that a Weapon lock/Head lock is not valuable at times (Jay Larsen Iron Gauntlet WIN!!!) but more often than not Trollbloods would rather beat your model to death than try to weapon lock/head lock your model. I believe this is a no brainer when looking at the result of the poll. Not to mention, Trollblood models hit SO HARD if they get there they may not kill whatever it is but they will cripple it and follow up with something that can wreck/kill it. I know there are good uses for this power attack but they take such a high level of play to think about the Pro's of locking an Avatar sword arm versus just trying to wreck him that most players will go with the latter. Happy smashing, brothers (and sisters). 

One Handed Throw 6 (5%) 

Rules: A model cannot throw a model with a larger base. A warjack/warbeast must have at least one non-crippled Open Fist to make a throw power attack. 

The attacking model makes a melee attack roll against its target. If the attack hits, both models roll a d6 and add their current STR. If the target's total is greater, it breaks free without taking any damage and avoids being thrown. If the attacker's total equals or exceeds the target's, the target model is thrown. 

Being Thrown: When your model throws another, choose a direction for the thrown model to be moved. This direction must be away from the attacker. Measure a distance from the target equal to half the attacker's current STR in inches along the chosen direction to a point on the table. This point is the thrown model's intended point of impact. A large- or huge-based model throwing a small-based model adds 1" to this distance. 

From this point, determine the thrown model's actual point of impact by rolling for deviation. Roll a d6 for the direction and a d3 for the distance in inches. The deviation distance cannot exceed half the distance between the thrown model and the intended point of impact. 

The thrown model is moved directly from its current location in a straight line to the determined point of impact. A thrown model moves through models with smaller bases during this movement without contacting them. Unlike when a model is slammed, rough terrain and obstacles do not affect this movement, but the thrown model still stops if it contacts an obstruction or a model with equal or larger sized base. The thrown model is then knocked down and suffers throw damage. If a thrown model cannot be knocked down it must still forfeit its action or movement if it activates later in a turn in which it was thrown. 

If a thrown model would end on top of another model, that model is contacted. Follow the rule of least disturbance (p.64) to move models into legal positions. 

A thrown model falls off elevated terrain if it ends its throw movement with less than 1" of ground under its base. See "Falling" (p. 63) for detailed rules on determining damage from a fall. Resolve any falling damage simultaneously with throw damage. 

Throw Damage: Apply throw damage after movement and knockdown effects, regardless of whether the model actually moves or is knocked down. The thrown model suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attacker's current STR. Add an additional die to the damage roll if the thrown model contacts an obstruction or a model with an equal or larger-sized base. Throw damage can be boosted. 

Collateral Damage: If a thrown model contacts a model with an equal or smaller-sized base, that model is knocked down and suffers collateral damage. A model suffering collateral damage suffers a damage roll with a POW equal to the attacker's current STR. Collateral damage cannot be boosted. A contacted model with a larger base than the slammed model does not suffer collateral damage and is not knocked down. Resolve any collateral damage simultaneously with slam damage. Collateral damage is not considered to be damage from an attack or model. For example, an effect triggered by being "damaged by an enemy attack" would not trigger due to collateral damage.  

one-hand throw

My Thoughts: Why one handed throw when Trolls have 4 heavies and at least as many lights and a colossal that all have 2 open fists to double handed throw with. Because of deviation, this makes this power attack good if you just want to throw a model outside of an opponent's control area, but if you hope to throw a model at a certain place, I believe, deviation is going to screw you more often than not. Of course you can always throw a model at an obstruction or huge based model and hope for contact so you get the extra damage die in addition to being able to boost the throw damage. 

Double-Hand Throw 74 (71%) 

Rules: A model cannot throw a model with a larger base. A warjack/warbeast must have two non-crippled Open Fists to make a double-handed throw power attack. The attacking model make a melee attack roll against its target. If the attack hits, the target model rolls a d6 and adds its current STR. The attacker rolls 2d6 and adds its current STR. If the target's total is greater, it breaks free without taking any damage and avoids being thrown. If the attacker's total equals or exceeds the target's, the target model is thrown. 

To determine the direction of the double-hand throw, the attacker can either follow the steps for determining the direction of a regular throw (see "Being Thrown," previous) or simply throw the model at another model within the attacker's line of sight. Ignore the model being thrown when determining line of sight to the other model. The throw distance is equal to half the attacker's current STR in inches. A large-based model throwing a small-based model adds 1" to this distance. If the other model is within range, the attacker makes a melee attack roll against it. If it is outside this range, resolve the throw using the rules in "Being Thrown" as if the thrown model were thrown directly toward the other model. On a hit, move the thrown model from its current location directly toward the other model's base until it contacts the target. This throw does not deviate. A double-hand throw at another model is not an attack against that model. In either case, the direction must be away from the attacker as with other throw power attacks. 

If the attack rolls misses, determine the thrown model's point of impact by rolling deviation from the center of the other model's base. Referencing the deviation rules, roll a d6 for direction and a d3 for distance in inches. The deviation distance cannot exceed half the distance between the thrown model and the intedned point of impact. 

If the other model is beyond the throw distance, determine deviation from a point on the line to it equal to the throw distance. The thrown model moves directly from its current location in a straight line to the determined point of impact. 

A thrown model moves through models with smaller bases during this movement without contacting them. Unlike when a model is slammed, rough terrain and obstacles do not affect this movement, but the thrown model still stops if it contacts an obstruction or a model with equal or larger sized base. The thrown model is then knocked down and suffers throw damage. If a thrown model cannot be knocked down it must still forfeit its action or movement if it activates later in a turn in which it was thrown. 

If a thrown model would end on top of another model, that model is contacted. Follow the rule of least disturbance (p.64) to move models into legal positions. 

A thrown model falls off elevated terrain if it ends its throw movement with less than 1" of ground under its base. See "Falling" (p. 63) for detailed rules on determining damage from a fall.

Resolve any falling damage simultaneously with throw damage. Resolve damage resulting from a double-hand throw using the "Throw Power Attack," "Throw Damage," and "Collateral Damage" rules above.  

doublehand throw

My thoughts: Imagine if you will a key model is 10" away from a Mauler. You use his Animus and he is under the Protective Aura with +1 STR. There is a Fennblade standing in front of you. You can spend one to Double Handed Throw your Fennblade at that model. With STR 15 +3 from Rage and +1 from Protective Aura you throw 10" away at the model you want to go away. The beautiful thing about a double handed throw is that the attack that happens to the target model uses the throwing model's MAT, not RAT. A throw is not a ranged attack. So, at MAT 6 you can still boost the attack and damage and the Mauler can completely smash a model into another model. Another important thing to consider here is that when you throw a model at Saeryn during her feat you use your MAT to hit her but it is not considered an attack on her at all so it bypasses her feat and she will be knocked down and take the damage if you can hit her. 

After posting this poll I realized that if I was going to write an article about Power Attacks I needed to include those Power Attacks specific to Gargantuans/Colossals. So, I posted a shorter poll about those Power Attacks. Only eight voters participated in that poll, but as we explore Power Attacks more we may find out why that is. The results of the poll look like: 

Power Strike 1 (12%) 

Rules: A colossal making a power strike power attack uses the force of its tremendous melee power to send a smaller-based model flying. A colossal must have at least one non-crippled Open Fist to make a Power Strike power attack. Its target must be in the Open Fist's field of fire and have a smaller base than the colossal. 

The colossal makes a melee attack against the target. If the attack hits, the target is slammed d6 + 2" directly away from the colossal. The POW of the slam damage roll and the POW of collateral damage rolls results from the slam are equal to the STR of the colossal.  

power strike

My thoughts: Like all power attacks this one is situational. If you have an opportunity to walk up to a large-based model and power Strike it into a group of models that would charge it next turn it might be something to do but at the risk of your opponent shaking the knockdown, charging and killing your Colossal/Gargantuan on their turn. It seems reasonable to believe that if a single model is close enough to your Colossal/Gargantuan you would just kill it where it stands rather than using the power attack. The exception is the next one, Power Sweep. However, there is one tactic I read that sounded kind of funny to me and may work in a few instances. If you line up a whelp in front of the Mountain King and have your Mountain King Power Strike the whelp in the back and basically use the whelp like a bullet. I've never tried it and have no idea how effective it would be but since the Mountain king sheds whelps you could potentially have an endless supply of bullets. 

Sweep 7 (87%) 

Rules: A colossal can use its arms to scythe through models within its reach. A colossal must have at least one non-crippled melee weapon to make a sweep power attack. This model makes one melee attack with the weapon against each model in the weapon's field of fire that is within the model's 2" melee range. Models hit suffer a damage roll with a POW equal to the colossal's STR.  

sweep

My thoughts: The mighty Quarter Thresher! My only real problem with this power attack is that it only works in one field of fire and you can't do a Power Sweep on each side every turn. I understand that would be making TWO power attacks in one turn, but come on, it's a Colossal/Gargantuan. They already have special rules written for them. I think if your Mountain King is surrounded on one side a Power Sweep could be a good way to clear them off just remember you only get one Kill Shot spray at the end of the sweep, provided you kill a model during the sweep. 

I would like to apologize for the time it took for me to publish this article. I wanted to make sure I added the actual rules and procedures for these attacks because I think a lot of the misunderstanding people have about power attacks is they don't know what the ACTUAL rules are. They were taught how to play by playing with someone and the options either never came up or they were taught incorrectly or just misunderstood what they were being taught. Power attacks are a huge part of the Trollblood faction. There isn't a game I play where I don't think about Trampling to the enemy caster and beating their face. 

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.

~IAmSweeps
MKII-Troll-Logo-Thumb

Thursday, November 28, 2013

Did You Know? Annoying Whelps

Did you know that the -1 penalty to attack rolls from Whelps "Annoyance" do not stack with other Whelps that are also within 1" of the same enemy model?  
whelps

Applicable Rules:

Annoyance

Living enemy models within 1" of this model suffer -1 to attack rolls.


Rule Priority

"Multiple instances of the same effect are not cumulative even when the effect comes from different sources." (Prime MKII, p.29 and Primal MKII, p.29)   

As cool as it would be to stack enough whelps around a model to make them MAT, RAT, Magic Ability 0 or even negative you just can't do it. 

 ~IAmSweeps
MKII-Troll-Logo-Thumb
 

Tuesday, November 26, 2013

How Many Games Do I Have To Lose?

Welcome to another Kith, Kriel, and Kin article. As always, I am Kyle (IAmSweeps on the various interwebs).

I decided to shift around my planned article schedule to take some extra time to prepare the Power Attack Tips and Tricks article I am working on. In this article I want to talk about a topic that ALL beginners struggle with, no matter what faction they play. "How many games do I have to lose to get good at this game?" 

When I think about this topic the first thing that pops into my head is the scene from the movie Knockaround Guys where Taylor (Vin Diesel) says: "500 fights, that's the number I figured when I was a kid. 500 street fights and you could consider yourself a legitimate tough guy. You need them for experience. To develop leather skin. So I got started. Of course along the way you stop thinking about being tough and all that. It stops being the point. You get past the silliness of it all. But then, after, you realize that's what you are."
Vin-Diesel-Knockaround-Guys-500-fights


If you have never seen the movie, check it out. It's not too bad. I think it is fitting he is talking about being a "tough guy" and I write Trollblood articles. Get it?

The Problem

I was talking with a beginner Trollbloods player recently about this topic. He is having trouble with one specific caster but his frustration comes from the same root problem that beginners are going to lose, A LOT. He comes from 40k but is frustrated with not being able to catch on to this game quickly, given his prior war-gaming experience. I broke it down to him like this:

"The problem is there are over 120 casters in this game and at least 3 ways to play each one. So, that means you have to play 360 games at least 5 times to know how to play against every possible list in this game." These numbers are extremely general but I wanted to drive the point home that even if you play against every caster in the game one time that is over 120 games. But each caster can have an extremely varying list. After that, you have to account for in game play decisions, estimating that after 5 games with no changes to lists you will see enough variance in play to "maybe" understand that caster. All of this is assuming that you are using the same list for ALL of these games. Change your caster and you start the process all over again. So, 138 warcasters/warlocks with 3 variations played 5 times with 12 warlocks comes out to 24,840 games to play against every combination 5 times, and this is assuming you don't change your list at all. I won't go any farther with the ridiculous math because I'm hoping by now you get it. Luckily, not all warcasters/warlocks see a lot of play and those that do don't all have 3 different ways they are being played.

The Exploration Phase

One thing, I think, that stunts the growth of players is what I call "The Exploration Phase." This is where the player is looking at ALL of the models, units, casters, and beasts/jacks of their chosen faction and IT'S ALL SO BEAUTIFUL! The possibilities seem endless and nailing down exactly where to begin this journey isn't going to happen in this phase. Players buy the models that look cool and as many casters and they can afford right away so they can "mix it up" and try as many new things as they can come up with. Eventually they have played a number of games over what they believe is a decent amount of time to have learned their faction and they start looking at their win/loss record. For most this is a really bad ratio, well below 50%. This is the point where some players follow "The Obvious Solution" and others follow "The Less Obvious Solution".

The Obvious Solution

The Obvious Solution is a two part trap, I'm afraid. Sorry I didn't warn you ahead of time. One set of players will look at their failing win/loss record as a failure in their faction. This will lead to those players away and land them into a sea of new shinies and their exploration phase begins anew. The second set of players will quickly look at what lists have been successful in tournament play and make those lists. This is a better idea for the reactionary player because at least the list has seen success even if the player has not. This can still be a trap because the list they pick up is most likely a result of someone else's trials and tribulations developing it over a long time. They won't have that player's experience with the list to know how to pilot it. If they stick with the list and play it over and over against a wide variety of opponents then they shift over into "The Less Obvious Solution".

its-a-mouse-trap

The Less Obvious Solution

The Less Obvious Solution is for players that realize that, while exploration can be fun, players really need to specialize and hone specific skills sets to advance to higher levels of play. I listen to tons of podcasts and read as many articles as I can find online and I hear the same suggestion that I am going to say here, "Choose two casters and stick with them." I will add to that by changing it ever so slightly, "Choose one proven successful list in your faction and one caster to experiment with." This approach will give you a list with proven success that you can play over and over without worrying if the list is the problem or you. There will still be bad matchups that the "tried and true" list won't like to play against, but that is where the other list can come into play. You can experiment and tailor that second warlock's army to have decent matchups against those the first list doesn't like. By gosh, this sounds like tournament prep. It kind of is, but you can apply this to your local meta's game night(s), too.


roads-traveled

Knowledge is Power

Nothing can compare to experience but we must always remember that we play a game where the more you know the more prepared you are to deal with different situations. There are tons of resources that players who want to raise the bar for themselves should be using.


Warroom

So many people want to know ahead of time what model x and unit y do but don't want to pay for faction books. For the price of some units, you can buy every card that exists in the game, forever. This app is an amazing resource for not just what models do but it even explains rules that are on the card. Sure, it is missing key components like how to actually perform a power attack, but it still provides great detail into what factions have to work with. Any player with the time to look through factions they don't play and analyze, even a little bit, about what opposing factions bring to the table can turn around and look at what things they can bring in their lists to counter them.


Prime/Primal MKII

For the love of all that is holy/unholy/holy moley read the core rule book. Read it 5 times. Honestly, I think everyone should just flat out own a copy of either one (probably best for the game system you play). Many players learn to play the game on the table, with someone else teaching them. That is great and I will get into that more in a minute, but EVERY player should still read the core rules at some point, including the Battle Engine section of Wrath/Domination and Colossal/Gargantuan section of those books. There are far too many things that a player can do in this game for one person to teach you all of it in demo/battle box games. Even as you move through higher point games you will miss some thing you could have done that you never even knew was a thing. Privateer Press has these in digital form now so you don't have to worry about lugging around cumbersome books.

other-half-7cd53ca7d6f85f87f5190463b7e82624

Community Involvement

The last thing I want to discuss on this topic is Community Involvement. One of the coolest things about this community is that people are willing to share. As I am writing and you are reading and maybe you tell some friends about my articles or this site, full of articles from other community contributors, the data is flowing to any and all how reach out to get it. There are a multitude of places within this community to get even more information.


Podcasts

Listening to podcasts can give you a look into the heads of players of different areas of the country, or world, about what works, what doesn't, their thoughts, and the most important part (I think) is you get to know your community. After listening to at least the second half of the current episode count of Removed From Play I feel like I know Omnus and Bloodrath, at least a little. I know well enough I would love to go have a beer with them and talk Warmachine/Hordes.


Battle Reports

Battle reports can show you how a list is played. They come in audio and video form. I mean no offense to the audio versions but I prefer the video battle reports because I think they are a thing better shown than said. Endgamegaming.net is an amazing resource that everyone should use. They post lists that people use in tournaments, tournament results, videos, and the guy works extremely hard (by himself) to provide all of it to the community. Show that guy some love and use the site. One thing I do love about audio battle reports is the commentary. Chain Attack and Removed From Play: Into the Arena are the two I listen to. If there are more I should check out people should let me know. I am always hungry for more podcasts to listen to while I ride my bicycle. The format for these battle reports is really nice because you hear what the player's priorities are going into the turn, their rough plan for the turn, and then the result.


Facebook/Social Media

I was lucky to stumble upon the Trollbloods facebook group by searching one day. The members of that group are so helpful. We definitely don't agree on everything but the level of constructive criticism vs. flaming/trolling is so much higher than anywhere else I have found. It sometimes makes me forget that forums even exist. I don't know if there is a group such as this for every faction but it is definitely something worth searching for.


Forums

Forums are a grey area. There are many of them available and they CAN be extremely helpful. They often times have a negative reputation because they have been used to express heated opinions about releases or lack of releases or reactions to things going on in other forums and not a lot of solid information. Luckily for Trollblood players there is a super sweet sticky section of the Privateer Press Trollblood Forum. This sections has been compiled by a few but has many contributors. Anyone who hasn't discovered the wonders here should stop reading this article and go there...or finish the article, then go.


LGS

We can't talk about anything related to community without talking about the Local Gaming Store (LGS). Without these sacred monuments there probably wouldn't be much of a physical community. A physical place to get together with other people who like the same thing you like and want to talk about it and experience it together, sounds too good to be true. Well, these places exist and we should all find and support ours. There are probably many other community resources I haven't named and it definitely isn't meant to slight anyone. The important thing to take away is remove yourself from your basement and get out there and become a part of something bigger than yourself. You will experience growth like you never thought you could.


success-kid

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.

~IAmSweeps
MKII-Troll-Logo-Thumb

Friday, November 15, 2013

How Much Support is Too Much?

Welcome to another Kith, Kriel, and Kin article. As always, I am Kyle (IAmSweeps on the various interwebs). 

In this article I want to talk about balancing the support in your lists. My hope is that you will gain a better understanding of how to choose which support models/units to bring to ensure your battle plan can work. Most of us know, by now, that Trollbloods are a faction that thrives on synergy. The number of models that provide support to the army in some fashion are huge. Uniquely, Trollbloods have a problem when it comes to support. Many of our support models can also mix it up in the battle, blurring the lines of what are purely support pieces. Most people don't forget that a Fell Caller Hero is a weapon master with two attacks, but they don't want to commit him to a fight and lose him. He also has a really decent spray that can be used throughout the battle. The Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes have really pathetic attack stats, but in a list with a Fell Caller Hero under the command of eMadrak, they become MAT 7 P+S 12 weapon masters. Heck, even Janissa Stonetide has armor piercing on her melee attack. This makes the question of how many points of support we bring extremely difficult because every support model, except for the Trollkin Runebearer I would say, adds a fighting body to the army.

Balancing Your List

In the Pokemon Card game there is a general rule for beginners that says your deck should be comprised of:
  • 10-25 Energy cards to support the types of Pokemon in your deck
  • 10-20 Pokemon
    • 50% Should be Basic Pokemon
    • 30% should be Stage 1
    • 20% should be Stage 2
    • Your Pokemon should have attacks and abilities that synergize well together
  • The rest of your deck should be Trainers/Supporters
    • Use Trainers that reduce/remove damage from your Pokemon
    • Use Supporters that let you search your deck for important cards
Dear, god. What have I done? I bring up this Pokemon example in a Warmachine/Hordes article because it illustrates the point that your support can either help you accomplish whatever plan you have set for your army or prevent your opponent from accomplishing theirs. How much support you bring will either increase your chances of your plan succeeding and blocking your opponent or you will struggle to execute your plan and your opponent will play their game, unhindered.
pikachu-pokemon
Unfortunately, there is not a nice little equation that you can use to plan your list in Warmachine/Hordes. You might try, but there are so many variables you have to consider and match ups to prep for. I took a poll over the past week to see if people thought there was a "magic number" for how many points should be dedicated to a 50 point Trollblood list. The results were:

In a 50 point Trollblood army, how many points should go towards support?

Points Votes
5 or under 2 (7%)
5 – 10 17 (65%)
10 – 15 6 (23%)
15+ 1 (3%)
Total number of votes: 26

The majority of people think that 5-10 points (or 10-20%) or your 50 point army should be support models/units. This seems reasonable at first glance but lets take a look at the support staff and see why it is difficult to commit to this 5-10 point bench mark.

I know that it will skew the discussion a bit but I am not going to include the Minions support that Trollbloods can take but you should understand that they account for another 15+ points of possible support for your list. I also understand that some people may consider the Fennblade Kithkar, Trollkin Champ Hero and Horthol to be support models because of their interaction with the Fennblade, Champions, and Longriders (respectively) units. I am leaving them out of the conversation as well because they are typically included in modules involving those units or as combat solos.

We visited most of these models in my Where to Begin? Breaking Into the Faction article, so some of this will be refresher.

Fell Caller Hero

Point Cost: 3
FA: 2
Support:
  • He can give Pathfinder to a friendly Faction warrior model/unit
  • He can increase the MAT of a friendly Faction warrior model/unit by 2
  • He can make all knocked down friendly Faction models in his CMD immediately stand up
WP_20130510_003 (1)

Janissa Stonetide

Point Cost: 3
FA: C
Support:
  • She can place a wall template completely within 5" of her
  • She can push all enemy models within 3" of her directly towards a table edge (may or may not be considered support)
WP_20130918_030 (1)

Stone Scribe Chronicler

Point Cost: 2
FA: 1
Support:
  • Can give a friendly Faction unit Concealment and Feign Death
  • Can give a friendly Faction unit +2 to melee attack and damage rolls against models in the melee range of friendly faction warbeasts.
  • Can knock down any warrior model who kills a member of a friendly Faction unit with a melee attack.
WP_20131001_008 (1)

Troll Whelps

Point Cost: 2 (for 5 whelps)
FA: 3
Support:
  • Can heal a warbeast within 1" d3 HP (removing the whelp from play)
  • Living enemy models within 1" of this model suffer -1 to attack rolls
  • Can remove fury from a friendly Faction warbeast within 1" of a whelp (removing the whelp from play)
whelps

Trollkin Sorcerer

Point Cost: 1
FA: 2
Support:
  • Remove enemy upkeep spells from it's client unit
  • Enemy models that begin their activation in this model's command range lose eyeless sight, flight, and pathfinder during their activations
71076_TrollkinSorcerer_WEB

Krielstone Bearer & Stone Scribes + Stone Scribe Elder

Point Cost: 3 Leader and 3 Grunts/4 Leader and 5 Grunts + 1 Stone Scribe Elder UA
FA: 1
Support:
  • Protective bubble that gives +2 ARM for friendly Faction models inside
  • Grants immunity to continuous effects to anyone effected by Protective Aura
  • Grants +1 STR to anyone effected by Protective Aura
WP_20130901_003 (1)

Trollkin Runebearer

Point Cost: 2
FA: 1
Support:
  • Reduce the cost of one of your warlock's spells by one this turn
  • Once per game cast a 3 fury or less cost spell
WP_20131021_001 (1)

Analysis

As you can see, if you tried to shove the maximum amount of each support piece you would be sitting at 26 points, which doesn't leave a sufficient amount of your army to actually fight with. Cutting the FA's down to 1 you are still sitting at 17-18 points depending on min or max Krielstone unit. Even this isn't reasonable or necessary. Because of the nature of the game and the likelihood that you will have to face certain opponents your support choices narrow.

Looking at our options we have to look at each piece and ask the question, "Does this model help me execute my plan or prevent my opponent from executing theirs?"

In the case of the Trollkin Runebearer and Krielstone Bearer and Stones Scribes + Stone Scribe Elder the answer is almost always "Yes." Every one of our warlocks can benefit from a little fury help from reducing the point cost of even a single spell by one fury. This will give one more fury to put into the Krielstone or even camp for transferring.

The Krielstone unit is, luckily, an amazing and cheap investment for any list. Whether you bring a min unit or max unit I think we would unanimously agree that the Krielstone unit is better with the Stone Scribe Elder.
Janissa Stonetide is a character model and so she can only be in one of your lists in a character restricted format. So, one of your lists doesn't have to worry about accounting for her points because she can't be there. There are certain lists that people would agree that she NEEDS to be included. Any of the Doomshaper lists or Calandra probably really need Janissa to increase their survivability. However, there are plenty of lists that really do not need her. eMadrak most likely doesn't need her because Grim Salvation provides an interest defense mechanism. This makes a multi-list format great because you can work around the character restriction through strong pairing. Just don't try to pair Doomshaper and Calandra unless you find some way to keep them alive without Janissa.

If you aren't running a bunch of beasts then you probably don't need whelps in the  list.

If you don't think you are going to be running into enemy upkeep spells then the Trollkin Sorcerer may not be necessary, even if he only costs 1 point (back to this in a minute).

What you have left is Fell Caller Hero and Stone Scribe Chronicler. These two are semi-situational. I say that because they provide support for different plans. The Fell Caller provides an unconditional +2 MAT. This is great if you are trying to make low/average MAT troops able to hit average/above average DEF. As kind of a general rule I always say that if a model/unit has a base MAT of 7 or higher I don't need a Fell Caller (unless specifically planning to fight a lot of Circle beasts or other DEF 15+ stuff where blasts alone won't handle it). I really like, because I play against Circle a lot, to use a Fell Caller to make high MAT troops even higher. A lot of people say it is "overkill", but if I don't hit anything that sounds more like "underkill" (Cheesy, I know. True none the less.).

The Stone Scribe Chronicler is an oddity to me. He grants concealment and Feign Death. DEF 14 is just as easy to hit in most cases as DEF 12 so I think of the concealment as "whatever." This guy makes his money through Feign Death. I don't know how many times I have Fennblades with Tale of the Mists on them that pass their tough checks and because of Feign Death actually make it to my next turn. Well, it has been enough times that I look at the Stone Scribe Chronicler and REALLY want to put him in the list. It doesn't stop their, though. Heroes Tragedy is another money maker because if I send a mass of 1 hp infantry into front lines and they die, as 1 hp infantry tend to do, knocking down the enemy troops can make my counter attack much more effective. I really like the Stone Scribe Chronicler in lists with lots of 1 hp infantry. Putting Tale of the Mists or Heroes Tragedy on Warders or Champs doesn't really have the same effect because there is a decent chance that they won't even have to make a tough check during the turn it is on them. Charge of the Trolls is great when it happens but, in my opinion, if it is a main part of your plan your opponent is just going to kill all of your beasts and that plan is going to fail.

More often than not I find that if I have a Fell Caller Hero I don't need a Stone Scribe Chronicler or vice versa.

The Numbers

Looking at what we have here we can look at the support package for any list like this:
  • Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes 3 - Leader and 3 Grunts/4 - Leader and 5 Grunts + Stone Scribe Elder 1 (4/5)
  • Trollkin Runebearer (2)
  • Fell Caller Hero (3) or Stone Scribe Chronicler (2)

This gives us a nice, tidy, 10 point package to play with. I believe this is where the majority of the voters who participated in the poll were thinking. However when you add Janissa to the list she needs to be in we are sitting at 13 points of support and if that list is, say, an eDoomshaper super beasty list with whelps we are now sitting at 15. 10-15 was the second highest vote in the poll and maybe these additions were what those people were thinking about.
accounting-calculator-1-90357-m
I hope this article has given you some ideas about how to look at the support package for your army and how to balance the support you bring. We unfortunately can't always bring all that we want so we have to choose the most effective models for the plan we want to execute. I know we crunched a lot of really simple numbers in this article but this becomes a big part of balancing and finishing out a list. It is way too easy to nickel and dime your way to half of your list going toward things that are great but don't drive your list towards executing your plan. On that note. One of the most difficult things to do in any list is "Fill that last one point." Currently there are only three options for Trollbloods and they are all Minions. With the release of the Trollkin Sorcerer, we will have a great in Faction option for 1 point that can potentially fit into any list. Even if you don't plan on facing enemy upkeep spells you will still have "another fighting model" with a nice ranged magic attack.

Thank you for taking the time to read this article. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.

~IAmSweeps
MKII-Troll-Logo-Thumb