In this article I want to try my hand at a tournament prep/battle report article. I will explain the format of the tournament, go over my list building/prep process, then finish with an extremely brief report of the tournament itself. The ultimate goal for this is to create a series over 2014 documenting my progress. This article is being written in two parts: Before and After. So, the language in this article will change from the present (what I am doing now to prepare for this event) to the past (what the results of my efforts were).
The Tournament
The format for this tournament is 50 points, 2 Lists (2nd list optional) with Character Restrictions, Divide and Conquer (if you bring two lists), Death clock, using the SR2014 beta package, with 4-5 rounds depending on attendance.
List Building/Tournament Prep
As soon as Warmachine Weekend was over and probably a bit before that I decided that 2014 was going to be my first "Big year of Warmachine." I have competed in local events and weekly league play but haven't ventured out of my tiny pond. My goal for 2014 is to hit at least 2-3 Cons and as many tournaments as I can make it to. I may find this is a little ambitious but I want to have a goal to strive for. Speaking of goals, another one I have set for myself is to consistently finish at a win-loss record of X-1. It would be extremely naive of me to think I am going to come out swinging, for the first time, and win every game I play. So, I think an X-1 average is attainable and over the course of the year, very possible.
I've decided that to have the best chance of attaining any of my goals I am going to have to commit to a set of lists for most, if not all, of the competitive play I would participate in. One list I have committed to for the entirety of 2014 is pDoomshaper Runes of War. It is widely believed to be "The strongest list in Trollbloods" so I thought that would be a great start to a list pair. Before I ever started playing Trolls I looked at pDoomshaper and knew he was a caster I wanted to play, so it is great that I have a strong option with him. The list may change as I get more experience with it but to start off my journey with it my Runes of War is the ever famous:
pDoomshaper (+7)
-Mulg the Ancient(12)
-Earthborn Dire Troll(10)
-Dire Troll Mauler(9)
-Troll Axer(6)
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes(Max) + Stone Scribe Elder (5)
Janissa Stonetide(3)
Runeshapers(3)
Runeshapers(3)
Runeshapers(3)
Runeshapers(3)
I really like this set up because I feel like the list is very streamlined in your activations and in game options and starting the game with 2 wall placements and 5 fury already in the Krielstone is pretty sweet. I will get into matchups after I go over the journey and evolution of my second list.
When thinking about a second list to pair with Runes of War I had to answer the question "What do I drop Runes of War against?" I talked with the Trollblood Facebook group, scoured the interwebs for anything on Runes of War, watched videos, and talked directly with Jason Flanzer (the inspiration for the build I am running). The end result of all of that research revealed that, according to the masses, Runes has game against everything except Cryx, Khador, and Menoth.
After the finals of Warmachine weekend I felt a lot of pressure to pick up pGrim for his strength against Cryx. I picked him up and began my usual dojo process. I spent some time crunching list ideas and speaking with friends that actually play pGrim on a regular basis to try and learn what his deal is and I finally came up with this list to put on the table and test:
Grim Angus
-Dire Troll Bomber
-Troll Impaler
-Storm Troll
War Wagon
Gatorman Witch Doctor
Stone Scribe Chronicler
Fennblade Kithkar
Max Fennblades + UA Max
Cylena Raefyll & Nyss Hunters
I really wanted to abuse the DEF lowering capabilities of Grim's feat and the knockdown gun on the War Wagon to set up caster assassinations with the Bomber and Nyss Hunters while the rest of the army tied up and took out infantry. I admittedly only played one game with it and I hit all of the things I was hoping to do. I used the War Wagon to knock down the caster but the rest of my guns didn't have enough punch to really damage the caster. I wont go into great detail about the game but it was eIrusk camping 5 and I was only able to do something like 3 damage and I wasn't going to get another opportunity to assassinate again. The long story short of it was that particular game went so poorly it shook my confidence in the lists ability to perform the task I was setting for it. If it could kill old man Irusk at 15/15 how was it going to do any better against a caster with better defensive stats? I know one game should not dictate anything about changing a list or scrapping it but I knew I didn't have too many practice games before the actual event so I needed to decide what I was going to do.
I listen to ALL the podcasts (probably) and one thing that I know comes up over and over is playing what you are comfortable with. This is an obvious piece of advice that is easy to forget when preparing for an event that you don't know what you will play against but ultimately have to fall back on.
I decided my second list needed to answer the general question of infantry. I am happy to say that whenever an infantry swarm approaches my lady pGrissel will answer the call to battle. It helps that she happens to be my favorite caster in Trolls (not my favorite model, but PP is going to do right and fix that for us...please) so as far as comfort level is concerned, it doesn't get better for me.
I have so many versions of lists for her so this was actually a tough build for me. I decided that my list is going to be, barring any wild considerations that present themselves in the next day:
Grissel Bloodsong, Fell Caller(+5)
-Storm Troll(5)
-Pyre Troll(5)
Fennblade Kithkar(2)
Stone Scribe Chronicler(2)
Fel Caller(3)
Horthol, Long Rider Hero(5)
Krielstone Bearer and Stone Scribes(Min) + Stone Scribe Elder (4)
Warders(Max)(8)
Fennblades(Max) + UA(10)
Longriders(Max)(11)
Once I set my list pair I began to think about what I "know" the lists can do rather than what I have researched and dojoed that they should be able to do. From list I have broken down my list drops in this manner:
pDoomshaper (Runes of War):
-Legion
-Cygnar (w/ Stormwall)
-Minions
-Skorne
-Trolls (Beast Heavy/Brick)
-Convergence
pGrissel:
-Circle
-Cryx
-Khador
-Cygnar(w/o Stormwall)
-Trolls (Infantry)
-Menoth
-Retribution
I doubt anything here is terribly surprising except for maybe my choice to drop pGrissel against Circle. Even that might not be too far fetched when you consider how much anti-magic Circle has at their disposal and I have a lot of practice against Circle and feel most comfortable with Grissel in that matchup. Runes of war is my heavy target removal. So, matchups I expect to see a lot of beasts and armor and Grissel is my infantry drop, as I said before. This may seem really simple but I don't have enough experience against enough things to complicate my thought process worrying about specific skews that I may not even see.
The Event
The event was 5 rounds with 21 players. We ended up only needing to play 4 rounds due to pairings and results up to that point. Prior to starting the tournament I walked around checking out what factions were being represented. All of the Warmachine factions were there (even Retribution) and not many Hordes factions. The first round always seems to be the most important as it sets the tone for the day. If you lose the first round then the day typically becomes just for fun but if you win the first round your day becomes a lot more stressful as you try and fight your way to the top. My initial thoughts were that if I could play against an infantry swarm first round I would have a great day...
Round 1: vs. Khador (Bob Tippett)
Scenario: Destruction (2014)
List Selection: I can't remember what my opponent's two casters were. I knew I was playing pGrissel as soon as I saw Khador. This is a matchup I am very comfortable with and I knew I was going to eventually swing the game towards a scenario win. My opponent dropped Vlad3. This is what I remember of his list: Vlad3
-Drago
-War dog
Uhlans(max)
Greylord Cav(max)
Fenris
Markhov
2x doomreavers
Great Bears
Game highlights: I went second ALL day. We sent our forces flying at each other turn one. Turn two he reminded me to respect what Dash does, despite my "good" spacing. I feated turn 2 and cleared most of the zone and jammed darn near my whole army in. He tried to get his Greylord Cav into my support with Dash turn 3 but they either didn't hit with their sprays or couldn't crack armor. My turn 3 I killed the far objective scoring the first point of the game and tried and failed to remove Drago from the zone, the only enemy contesting. Turn 4 I cleared the zone but still had my Longriders to activate and managed to assassinate Vlad camping maybe 1, but I think he was empty (which is the only reason my I went for it), with a Longrider impact/charge.
This was a great game and my opponent was awesome. This was my first tournament game in months and a great way to knock the dust off. One thing I am not sure about, because of the way that Steamrollers work, is whether it would have been better to dominate the zone that turn and position so there was no way for his army to get into the zone and eventually win on scenario or take the caster kill. In the end I thought winning the game for sure was better than giving my opponent a need to go for a 10% assassination and pulling it off (I have a history of losing games by 10%-ers). My list surprised me. When building it, and really any time I build a list for pGrissel, I built it to fight the scenario, not my opponents army. I go into the game knowing I am playing for scenario from the start and play my turns with that in mind. I never even look for assassination, but that is how I won. Spoiler alert: That is how I got all of my wins at this event.
Round 2: vs. Cryx (Dan Sammons)
Scenario: Fire Support (2014)
List Selection: I know my opponent had a pSkarre and eSkarre list. I chose pGrissel again and he chose pSkarre with 1 million dudes. I don't have a lot of experience against Cryx and it is mostly pDenny so I wasn't totally sure what to expect except for 1 million dudes who keep coming back.
Game highlights: This was kind of a lame game (sorry, Dan). Since I have no experience against Skarre I played really timid and Dan was able to tie me up too easily. I made a move on my feat turn and put Grissel farther forward than she needed to be, trying to catch as many different units with Cacophony as I could. 2 Helldivers took all of my 3-4 transfers with some pretty hot dice and Skarre's feat and he managed to assassinate Grissel top of 3.
Cryx is one of those matchups I know Trolls have problems with. In my local area we don't have some dabblers but no hard core Cryx players. I learned a lot from the game that I will take with me into future events, like models that can clear off enemy models from my front line troops so when they activate they can actually advance up the board. Scattergunners seem like the obvious choice but even trying to squeeze a min unit plus UA at 7 points into the list is rough. I will share my other ideas at the very end of the article.
Round 3: vs. Cryx (Alex Johnson)
Scenario: Supply and Demand (2014)
List Selection: My opponent only brought one list pDenny with a Kraken. When I saw the list I immediately saw the Kraken and knew this was my time to drop Runes of War. With Banishing Ward, Purification, Magic attacks during her feat, and the potential to outright kill her on my feat turn if she decides to cast anything seemed too good to pass up. Not to mention I hadn't played my second list yet so I wanted to make sure I put it down so I wouldn't get locked in later in a really bad match up. I know at this point since I have lost one I'm probably not competing for any top spot but I still wanted to finish the day with only one loss so I was going to play the day like I won every round.
Game highlights: I can't make any excuses about this game. We both played the best games we could and, in the end, Hoarluk died top of 2. I managed to take out War witch sirens and pistol wraithes with Runeshapers. He singled out and completely took Mulg out of the game. I had Banishing Ward on Doomy and feated at the perfect time. He had to move Denny way into the kill box to cast scourge, without dying to the feat, on a model that was too close to Doomy and knocked him down and Kraken came and ate him. I don't really know how else I could have played the game, except to choose the other side of the board. As I said earlier in the article I went second EVERY game. This is the one game I did not look at the terrain state ahead of time and just deployed on the side I was standing. There was a piece of obstructing terrain that made me split in a funny way, which made one of my units of Runeshapers completely useless during the game trying to maneuver around it. Other than that, we played out best and the biggest liability to me list shined through, Doomy himself. More on this later.
Round 4: vs. Retribution (Chris Smith)
Scenario: I don't remember the name of it but it had a vertical rectangle zone in the middle with a friendly flag and enemy flag with some cool new mechanics coming in 2014.
List Selection: My opponent had a Ravyn (I assume snipe, feat, go) list and an eVyros Griffon spam list. After my top of two loss with Doomy I didn't want to risk him just getting shot off the table so I went with pGrissel for the last round. She is a bit sturdier and I felt ok with having to deal with shooting troops. We both surprised each other because he thought I was going to drop Runes of War and chose eVyros and I thought he would choose Ravyn and chose pGrissel.
Game highlights: Everything was going just fine (jam, model trading, no one scoring scenario points) until his synergy chain was getting to a point where Battledriven Warders were getting hit with dice plus 4 against their armor. This was the point where I was actually worried that my army couldn't take the punishment. I can't remember if it was turn 3 or 4 but I had an opportunity to go for assassination and went for it without calculating the odds of success. Vyros was bare and there was a Phoenix that came poking out to kill longriders. I Bull Rush slammed Phoenix into Vyros, knocking him down. Then I buffed a Battledriven Warder with the Pyre Troll animus and Heroic Ballad (to get an extra attack if needed) and charged the knocked down caster and killed him with the first attack.
There was a little controversial moment during the assassination run where my Longrider came into melee range of one of my opponent's reach jacks. My opponent thought he would get a free strike on my Longrider prior to the slam but because his jack had 360 degree vision and I never left his melee range the free strike wouldn't happen.
I feel like I definitely got lucky in this game. I played for scenario as much as I could, but as soon as he started to one shot Warders off the table I knew I needed to finish the game with a caster kill or eventually he was going to kill my caster.
Conclusions/The Take Away One thing that struck me is just how many rounds I looked at my opponents list(s) and thought "Why did I even bring Runes of War to this event?" Every time I just felt pGrissel had a better shot at winning. The one round I dropped Runes was so I wouldn't be locked into it in the last round, not that I was in contention for anything, but I wanted to play through the tournament like I had won every round to try and get better at list selection.
Another thing that surprised me was that both games I won were by caster kill. When I build pGrissel, I plan to fight the scenario, not my opponents army and certainly not their warcaster. That is the question that I ask my opponent, "Can you prevent me from scoring points and winning on scenario before you?" Since Strength of Schedule is a thing and CPs carry a lot of weight in that I build with that plan in mind. What I found playing the list, is that it does have a very strong assassination option. I won't forget to look for that option when I play her moving forward.
Looking ahead, within my local meta, there exists a very different army composition than I expected to see. In light of this, I will probably not play Runes of War in local tournaments unless a big shift occurs. Looking around at who plays what on a regular basis I just don't see enough strong match ups to drop the list. I will, however, continue to familiarize myself with it and keep it ready for any cons I make it to in 2014. I expect that with a much broader field represented there will be more opportunities to make use of Runes. I know how it must sound, since at the beginning of this article I am confident in announcing Runes of War as my locked in primary list, and now placing it in a "maybe" as my second list. After seeing the field I will play against, locally, I'm just not as confident as I was before. Like I said, I still want to gear it up for larger events. So, I'm not dropping it all together.
My next tournament is January 25th. It will be the same format as this event. One thing I would like to try, preparing for this event, is drop my long riders to a min unit and add a unit of Runeshapers to the list. At magic ability 7 I hope to use their rock hammer ability to clear off models from my front line so they are free to charge forward. As I said earlier, a min unit of Scattergunners plus UA would probably be ideal but I feel like my list would suffer from all of the changes that would have to happen for that. It is also possible that after testing the Runeshapers I will not change anything, just work on positioning my Kithkar to clear off pesky jammers. I would rather use the activation of a single model to clear off my front line than a unit. Even as I write this, I think that is the better option. Since the long riders were crucial in my assassinations I would hate to reduce their effectiveness by making their unit smaller.
As far as my second list for my next event, tune in next time.
Thank you for taking the time to read this article. As with all Kith, Kriel, and Kin articles this is not meant to be the end of the discussion but, rather, the beginning.
~IAmSweeps
No comments:
Post a Comment